Articles

Harriet Crisp

The Gleaners and I (2000)

Taking the traditional definition of gleaning as the act of collecting leftover crops from fields after they have been harvested as its starting point, The Gleaners and I (2000) investigates various forms of gleaning through a zigzagging journey across the French landscape. Along the way, Agnes Varda interviews vagabonds, activists, artists, and individuals who forage and scavenge to get by, whilst reflexively gleaning images and ideas with her handheld camera. 

 

Following the form of Varda’s earlier documentary Daguerrotypes (1975), The Gleaners and I weaves together vignettes of different people, captured through conversational interviews. Through these portraits, the varied reasons people glean are revealed: out of hunger; alongside others to gain a sense of community; to gather material for artworks; to practice ethical beliefs; to remember a period of one’s life; and for the pure pleasure the act produces. The settings are equally diverse: the activity of urban gleaners who gather from bins and pavements are presented alongside that of those gleaning in the French countryside. The law and history surrounding gleaning in France is established by lawyers in full robes who appear, suddenly and surreally, in a field of dying cabbage and from the hustle and bustle of a busy street.

 

Just as the documentary’s subjects see treasure in the trash, through careful and ludic camerawork Varda enchants the everyday. The camera slowly grazes over cabbage leaves and the seeded centres of sunflowers, through which they appear as beautiful landscapes-in-miniature. Elsewhere, Varda films one hand with the other, “catching” trucks as they pass by on the motorway by encircling each in her fist held in front of the lens. Later, the camera is accidentally left running, its lens cap swinging across a view of the ground. Accompanied by a soundtrack of carefree jazz, Varda presents this footage as ‘The Dance of the Lens Cap’. At other points, through Varda’s voiceover, a yellowing bunch of parsley is transformed into a bouquet of flowers and black ceiling mould is framed as ground-breaking abstract art.

 

Varda’s filmmaking process of gathering footage and thoughts with her camera is itself an act of gleaning. This parallel is surfaced through clever self-reflexivity from the documentary’s offset. The documentary opens with images of Varda imitating the female gleaner in Jules Breton’s painting ‘La Glaneuse’, replacing a sheaf of wheat with a camera. Handheld throughout, the camera becomes an extension of Varda’s hand, roving and reaching out to objects of interest, including the heart-shaped potatoes which are the film’s central motif. Voiceover offers another means for Varda to reflect on her filmmaker-gleaner status, and she does so thoughtfully, describing her process as the gleaning of “images, impressions, emotions”.

 

As is typical in the road movie genre, which the documentary plays upon, the journey taken extends beyond the road trip to encompass interior reflection. Varda looks within, meditating on her creative process, memory, and aging through voiceover and image. Her changing body is presented as a landscape alongside that of the French countryside. Images depict her combing her hair, striped down the centre with grey roots, and her wrinkled hands in close-up. In the voiceover which accompanies these images, Varda reflects on the awe and horror she feels towards her anatomy.

 

In The Gleaners and I Varda stages an intimate and layered inquiry into the histories and practices of gleaning in France. At once playful, political, and profound, the documentary offers a meandering rumination on waste, aging, beauty, justice, and life’s quandaries and purpose.

 

Published 15 Apr 2024


Harriet Crisp

Around China With a Movie Camera (2015)

A travelogue constructed through assemblage, Around China with a Movie Camera (2015) weaves together excerpts from films in the British Film Institute National Archive to form a far-reaching journey across China during the first half of the twentieth century. The original contexts of the films vary widely from travelogues, newsreels, and documentaries to  home movies and missionary films, but all were made by British and European visitors. Accompanying this melange of images of people, architecture, and landscapes, a lively score by Ruth Chan knowingly fuses Chinese and Western music.

 

Ordered by location rather than temporal instance, the programme drifts from bustling Beijing to the more rural provinces and back to the hubbub of Hong Kong and Shanghai. The images document cultural practices lost to time: cormorant fishing, ivory carving, water-buffalo-powered systems for irrigating paddy fields, and street performers balancing with stacks of bowls atop their heads. The programme closes with what is thought to be the oldest known surviving film shot in China: flickering images of men in traditional dress chatting to one another as sunlight dapples through branches overhead. As the programme motors through time and space, revealing entire lifetimes within seconds of film, the viewer has that strange feeling of the incomprehensible vastness of past lives lived the world over.

 

The edging Westernisation of the country is evident in the footage. Vaccinations, motors cars, British and German soldiers, and less traditional clothing and buildings are depicted in the later films. This Western influx is echoed in the imperial gaze enacted in the images. Though severed from their original contexts, where this dynamic is at times starker, the British and European perspective of the films is clearly felt. The movie camera operates at a distance to its subjects, gaping and staring, producing images of a culture that the camera’s operator does not belong to. Images rendered in Pathécolour or tinted with jewel-like tones appear as psychedelic, over-saturated holiday postcards, visions rather than representations of the people and places.

 

This encounter of East and West is deftly reflected in the programme’s score. Ruth Chan melds a blend of Chinese opera, folk music, and traditional melodies with Western classical, jazz, and electronic music. The programme’s title is a nod to Dziga Vertov’s A Man with a Movie Camera (1929), a seminal city symphony, and Chan’s score follows in the vein of the soundtracks composed for this epic urban documentary. Thrumming beats and building rhythms accompany the busy activity portrayed in the images and contribute to the programme’s sense of movement across time and space.

 

Around China with a Movie Camera conjures a rich and intriguing picture of pre-Revolution China from the outsider perspective of British and European filmmakers. An amalgamation of varied archival footage, the programme illustrates the value in film as a medium to understand histories of those both in front and behind the camera.

Published 15 Apr 2024

Get in touch

Have an article to submit?

Email BAHfilmfest@outlook.com